The investigators waded through near chest-high waters. They rode on swamp buggies and air boats and called in underwater dive teams to explore the reserve’s 25,000 acres. And they tried to avoid the many poisonous snakes, gators, palmetto bugs and swarms of mosquitoes that call the swamp home.
The identity of the remains is not yet clear, but Laundrie family attorney Steven Bertolino said “the probability is strong that it is Brian’s remains.” A source close to the investigation told CNN that the suspected human remains “appear to have been there a while.”
The suspected remains were found “about 2 to 3 miles inside the Carlton Reserve, or about a 45-minute walk” from the entrance at Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park, a connected nature area, North Port police spokesperson Josh Taylor said.
The discovery came at an area of the reserve that had been underwater, but recently dried out due to clearer weather, and had reopened to the public a day earlier. The search remains ongoing as teams of K-9 dogs and law enforcement continued to comb for any more evidence.
Lee County Sheriff Carmine Marceno visited the reserve Thursday and saw firsthand the “treacherous” conditions of the search.
“These are very, very difficult conditions,” he said. “You’re searching in areas that you just can’t walk up and look. It’s not like you’re searching a house or a car. These areas are huge and they’re covered by water.”
Petito, 22, disappeared on the trip amid tensions in their relationship, and Laundrie, 23, returned by himself to his parents’ home in Florida on September 1.
How the Carlton Reserve impacted the search
The search for Laundrie began in earnest on September 17 after his parents told authorities he had gone to the Carlton Reserve with a backpack days earlier and did not return home.
Since then, investigators have repeatedly tried to navigate through the foreboding landscape of the reserve.
“The Carlton Reserve is a vast and unforgiving location at times. It is currently (waist) deep in water in many areas,” North Port police said in a Facebook post last month. “This is dangerous work for the search crews as they are wading through gator and snake infested swamps and flooded hiking and biking trails.”
The search team has included a range of specialized vehicles and personnel for such an environment.
“We’re looking through wooded areas, we’re looking through bodies of water, we’re looking through swampy areas,” North Point Police Commander Joe Fussell said last month. “And we’re deploying the resources to be able to do that. We have air units, we have drones, we have the swamp buggies, air boats, multiple law enforcement agencies, we have ATVs, we have UTVs and we have officers on foot as well.”
“The palmettos out there alone are enough to trip you up, when you’re walking through them, when you stumble through them,” McEwen told CNN’s Chris Cuomo. “The mosquitoes will carry you off, anybody out there more than a day without mosquito spray, you’d go insane with the bugs getting you and everything else.”
In an ABC interview earlier this month, Laundrie’s sister, Cassie Laundrie, said he had previously taken trips for up to five days on the Appalachian Trail. She said her brother is a “mediocre survivalist.”
Robert Urban, founder and chief instructor of the Urban Survival Academy, said he believes it’s highly unlikely that someone who is not professionally trained in survival tactics would be able to survive in the reserve for this long.
“Florida’s climate is very, very difficult,” Urban told CNN. “I’m an expert with plenty of experience, and it would be everything that I could do to survive for (more) than three weeks. Someone with no experience, you cannot be lucky and survive in that sort of climate.”
CNN’s Randi Kaye, Christina Maxouris, Taylor Romine and Leyla Santiago contributed to this report.