in

The bachelor who sued 50 ladies for calling him a foul date turned up at one in all their houses even – although she did not give him her tackle – after she found on-line group that uncovered him

The bachelor who sued 50 ladies for calling him a foul date turned up at one in all their houses even – although she did not give him her tackle – after she found on-line group that uncovered him


A bachelor who sued 50 ladies for calling him a foul date turned up on the home of one of many ladies though she by no means gave him her tackle.

Stewart Lucas Murrey went to the Los Angeles dwelling of Kelly Gibbons at 10.45pm and returned once more days later at 8.45pm.

CCTV photos from the property seem to indicate him filming or taking photographs on his cell phone.

Gibbons had by no means met Murrey in individual and had solely briefly swapped messages with him on courting app Hinge earlier than texting. 

Stewart Lucas Murrey, the Los Angeles bachelor who unsuccessfully sued 50 women for putting his womanizing ways on blast

Stewart Lucas Murrey, the Los Angeles bachelor who unsuccessfully sued 50 ladies for placing his womanizing methods on blast 

Murrey went to the Los Angeles home of Kelly Gibbons at 10.45pm and returned again days later at 8.45pm

Murrey went to the Los Angeles home of Kelly Gibbons at 10.45pm and returned again days later at 8.45pm

 Murrey went to the Los Angeles dwelling of Kelly Gibbons at 10.45pm and returned once more days later at 8.45pm

Stewart Lucas Murrey at Gibbons' home with a friend

Stewart Lucas Murrey at Gibbons' home with a friend

Stewart Lucas Murrey at Gibbons’ dwelling with a good friend

Gibbons captured his visits to her house on a Ring camera

Gibbons captured his visits to her house on a Ring camera

Gibbons captured his visits to her home on a Ring digicam 

However he tracked her down and turned up unannounced to serve her papers in a defamation lawsuit he filed in opposition to her at a court docket in Los Angeles. 

In an electronic mail, Murrey claimed that he was the one to dam Gibbons over her ‘closely filtered footage’.

He defended turning up at her home late at night time to file the authorized papers.

Murrey mentioned: ‘A few the defendants have tried to evade service, even claiming they weren’t served once they truly have been.

‘Course of servers are very pricey when evasive defendants are concerned and people have been clearly the hours that she was obtainable to be served by video proof’.

Murrey and Gibbons communicated over Hinge and in text messages for three weeks in 2022

Murrey and Gibbons communicated over Hinge and in text messages for three weeks in 2022

Murrey and Gibbons communicated over Hinge and in textual content messages for 3 weeks in 2022

Gibbons, 32, an artist and author, advised DailyMail.com that the incident was ‘disturbing’ and left her deeply anxious about returning to her dwelling.

In response to Murrey’s feedback about her photographs being filtered, she mentioned: ‘How does one decide the results of filters on a face they’ve by no means truly seen in individual?’ 

Gibbons is one in all 50 ladies who Murrey, who calls himself a ‘scholar’, sued over his therapy in a viral Fb group known as: ‘Are We Courting The Similar Man?’ during which ladies made unflattering feedback about him.

In response to his civil grievance, these posts left him affected by ’emotional misery’, PTSD and ‘mortification’.

He’s searching for $2.6 million in compensatory and punitive damages.

This week a decide dismissed the case in opposition to Vanessa Valdes, one of many 10 ladies he named within the authorized papers, with the remainder within the technique of submitting their very own motions to have the case thrown out. 

‘Whereas I navigate this complicated case which entails a number of defendants in varied roles, I’m taking alternatives for procedural treatments arising from the deficiencies of (Valdes’ case being dismissed),’ Murrey advised DailyMail.com 

‘In all lawsuits, there are ups and downs. However the energy ought to belong to the general public within the type of a jury trial’.

Gibbons advised DailyMail.com that she messaged Murrey on Hinge and texted him for 3 weeks in 2022 however it did not go wherever.

‘When he was texting me it appeared extra logistical than I am used to in the case of making a connection,’ she mentioned.

The pair had a flirty exchange on Hinge and were teeing up to meet when she got cold feet

The pair had a flirty exchange on Hinge and were teeing up to meet when she got cold feet

The pair had a flirty trade on Hinge and have been teeing as much as meet when she bought chilly toes

‘It didn’t really feel like an informal chat I’d anticipate to have with somebody after matching on a courting platform. 

‘I dragged it one for a few weeks longer than I ought to of to try to suss him out

‘There have been no fewer than 10 or 11 requests for a date, at the least 5 requests for Facetime.

‘He was overdoing it with the compliments on my look which made me uncomfortable’.

Texts between Gibbons and Murrey present him telling her: ‘I like your ink in your fairly hand’ and ‘I like your vibe’.

At one level he known as her ‘stunning, delicate, intriguing, chill, enjoyable’ and ‘stunning Kel’.

In a single textual content Murrey requested her if she was free that night time, however she replied that it was ‘kinda fast discover’.

Issues turned bitter the day earlier than they have been as a consequence of meet for the primary time. 

Gibbons mentioned: ‘Then he known as me, an audio name. We would by no means spoken on the telephone earlier than.

‘We chatted for a minute after which he conferences known as his ‘lawyer’ onto the telephone. I assumed it was actually weird

‘I used to be OK, I’ve by no means spoken to him, he is calling me at 11am. As quickly as that occurred they started speaking to one another like I wasn’t on the telephone. I excused myself from the dialog.

‘I went on Hinge to verify his profile once more and I observed his profile wasn’t matched with me anymore.

‘I used to be shocked, we have been assembly the following day, he didn’t have any cause to unmatch me.’ 

In a textual content, Murrey tried to brush it off by saying: ‘It is simply loopy, too many ladies lol’.

When Gibbons advised him she was ‘getting a bit of nervous about assembly you for some cause’, he replied: ‘What’s your Insta? I will dm you’.

His subsequent message was: ‘Truly it is okay I am probably not on this anymore you are too erratic. I am not into dumb video games’.

When Gibbons advised him goodbye and that she hoped he would ‘discover what you might be on the lookout for’, he responded: ‘Get pleasure from complimenting your self if others do not lol’

Quickly after Murrey texted her once more, telling Gibbons that she had ‘violent temper swings’ and threatened to dam her.

Vanessa Valdes received these messages from Murrey, who sued her for defamation but her case was dismissed

Vanessa Valdes received these messages from Murrey, who sued her for defamation but her case was dismissed

Vanessa Valdes acquired these messages from Murrey, who sued her for defamation however her case was dismissed

Just a few months later, Gibbons found the ‘Are We Courting the Similar Man?’ Fb group, which was set as much as permit ladies to warn different ladies about males they’ve dangerous experiences with on dates or courting apps.

Her publish mentioned: ‘I am curious to see if anybody has met ‘Lucas’ in individual (I am undecided if that is even his actual title).

The publish went viral inside the Fb group, which was set to personal, with dozens of ladies commenting. 

Gibbons mentioned: ‘In my publish I did not say something about him. It isn’t: ‘It is a man who did this’. I did not need to make any assumptions. I’ve by no means met him.

‘The way in which he spoke to me, I would not need my buddies being spoken to love that so I needed to see if anybody else had skilled one thing comparable’.

In February 2023, virtually a yr to the day after Gibbons blocked Murrey she bought a message on Whatsapp from him. 

Murrey sued 50 women for defamation claiming they'd lied about him. The case was thrown out

Murrey sued 50 women for defamation claiming they'd lied about him. The case was thrown out

Murrey sued 50 ladies for defamation claiming they’d lied about him. The case was thrown out

In an obvious reference to the Fb group, it learn that he had ‘proof of your conspiracy to defame me’ and advised her she was being sued, including that her behaviour was ‘disgusting’.

In December that yr, Gibbons got here dwelling to search out some authorized papers on her again porch. She requested her constructing supervisor to overview the CCTV and noticed Murrey standing there at 10.45pm.

‘I wasn’t there on the time,’ Gibbons mentioned. ‘He confirmed up twice. December twelfth and December seventeenth, each instances dropping the papers out of an envelope

‘I by no means advised him the place I dwell, I by no means gave him my tackle. He went out of his solution to observe down the place I dwell. It is disturbing.

‘The second time my roommate was dwelling and advised me that anyone is knocking on the door however they did not reply.

‘He is holding his cellphone pointed at my home, my doorways and home windows. 

‘It is alarming. It heightens nervousness round safety… my roommates requested if I would put up a no trespassing signal which I did.

‘I would fairly not take into consideration how lengthy he could have spent monitoring down my dwelling tackle. I by no means even gave him my full title.

‘It is laborious to not be involved. When somebody is inciting utterly baseless authorized motion in opposition to dozens of individuals as a consequence of – for my part – a bruised ego, that is what I think about an unpredictable individual’

Murrey insists that he was the victim throughout

Murrey insists that he was the victim throughout

Murrey insists that he was the sufferer all through 

One other of the ladies who was sued by Murey was Valdes, however her case was thrown out beneath California’s anti-SLAPP laws, which is designed to fight nuisance lawsuits.

Her texts with Murrey present that he grew to become upset as a result of she had a male good friend in one in all her profile footage.

He wrote: ‘Why is there a man in your pic, genius?’

When she replied that she was ‘amused by the way you suppose me properly sufficient to speak to me like one your buddies’, he responded: ‘It is enjoyable watching you burn lol’

Valdes advised him she was ‘reporting your a**’ and advised him to ‘keep away from ladies and get assist’.

Murrey replied: ‘Good Vanessa Loser I am subpoenaing you are fool ‘report’ and probably suing you for defamation. Does it upset you that I’ve damaged no legal guidelines similar to it is authorized so that you can (be) a moron. By the best way, actual respectable ladies love me lol’.

One other message learn: ‘I am sorry your so jealous when rejected’.

Gibbons mentioned that she accepted service on Murrey’s lawsuit though it was improperly served to cease him coming again to her home once more.

She known as the case in opposition to her ‘frivolous’ and ‘baseless’ and mentioned she deliberate to file her anti-SLAPP movement quickly.



Read more on dailymail

Written by bourbiza mohamed

Bourbiza Mohamed is a freelance journalist and political science analyst holding a Master's degree in Political Science. Armed with a sharp pen and a discerning eye, Bourbiza Mohamed contributes to various renowned sites, delivering incisive insights on current political and social issues. His experience translates into thought-provoking articles that spur dialogue and reflection.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings

Olivia Dunne works out on the uneven bars and dazzles on the beam as LSU star continues her preparations for subsequent week’s NCAA Gymnastics Championships in Texas

Olivia Dunne works out on the uneven bars and dazzles on the beam as LSU star continues her preparations for subsequent week’s NCAA Gymnastics Championships in Texas

Coalition hopes to exorcise the ghost of Scott Morrison as Cook dinner dinner goes to the polls | Scott Morrison

Coalition hopes to exorcise the ghost of Scott Morrison as Cook dinner dinner goes to the polls | Scott Morrison